Help Wanted
Sat May 05 2001

I'm having a thick moment, if anyone can help me with this I would really appreciate it, from the bottom of my heart!

Could someone explain to me what the new comment system has to do with Censorship?

Most of the complaints I've heard about the new comment system I am happy that I can say there is a 50/50 feeling about them among the users and its just a matter of personal opinion whether you want to have secured or unsecured comments on.

A number of the users however are implying that by allowing unauthenticated comments you are allowing uncensored comments!

*Laughs*

Exactly who is doing the censorship? Is it us (Dear Diary) or the diarist?

Like I said, it's something that a lot of people are coming up with so I can only assume that I'm having a thick moment. I really don't see the connection between whether or not a diarist allows secured comments and any kind of censorship. After all, you may still leave your comment!

The only difference, as Steve has said previously, is that leaving a confirmed username means that you must identify yourself. Everyone has a big mouth on the Internet until they have to say who they are, then suddenly they go quiet.

Thinking about it, I guess that might be a form of censorship, but that's you censoring yourself, not us and not the diarist.

I look forward to the answers, this question isn't asked tongue in cheek, it's an honest question. If you think that it's censorship then please please please tell me why, I'm uneducated in such matters and need your help.

Matt.

7 Comments
  • From:
    TrOoLyBLoOLypRiNcEsSGeRLy (Legacy)
    On:
    Sat May 05 2001
    I completely agree with you. The new comment system is not "censoring" anyone. It's just forcing people to take responsibility for their actions!

    You aren't constraining peoples freedom of speech in any way. But they have to state their rudeness out in the light rather than being hidden by false sn's or remaining the 'Anonymous Coward'.

  • From:
    CounterParts (Legacy)
    On:
    Sat May 05 2001
    It is not censorship. That's my opinion anyway. You have given us the choice as to how to set up our diary even. I think it's a wonderful idea. I think you are doing a wonderful job. I don't understand why anyone is complaining. Please ... please don't get so frustraighted with them that you stop the DD website... okies? *safe hugs* I know there will always be some that won't agree ... but DD and the work y'all do here means so so much to the rest of us. I want you to know that. I also know I'm not a paid member yet ... but please understand I will be soon. (had to wait for the tax money to come in ... *soft laughs*) It is that I want y'all to have all the support you can get. If I can help in any other way ... I am willing to try. (that's not tongue n cheek either *winks*) Many loves.

    Blessed Be,
    Angel
    ^i^
  • From:
    WillowWisper (Legacy)
    On:
    Sat May 05 2001
    i used to go to little leauge ball games to watch my son's team...some of the parents would shout out rude comments to the umpire or even to the other team and the coach...it always amazed me how stupid a crowd of people act when an audience is watching. i started sitting in my lawn chair far away from the crowd, it was peaceful. move your lawn chair off to the side folks. the dust will settle with or without you flapping about it.
  • From:
    Jayrah (Legacy)
    On:
    Sat May 05 2001
    It isn't censorship. Censorship is...(Oh no! She's getting the dictionary out!)..."To examine and expurgate". All you're doing is giving diarists the option of allowing only signed up members to give comments. Censorship requires an actual removal of material. People who say it's censorship are just upset for some reason beyond me. Keep up the great work!
  • From:
    JaneDoe (Legacy)
    On:
    Sat May 05 2001
    My 2 cents can be found here:

    http://www.deardiary.net/show/diaries/5452/989020800

  • From:
    Unauthenticated Coward (Unauthenticated) (Legacy)
    On:
    Sat May 05 2001
    YOU GIVE US SOMETHING TO REBEL AGAINST, MATT AND STEVE.

    Go away and leave us alone. No, come back, the system's been down too long, and it's not fair to us users.

    RAGE AGAINST THE SYSTEM!!!! OH CRAP. I found another zit.
  • From:
    Loner (Legacy)
    On:
    Sat May 05 2001
    Matt, I think you have a point. Anyway, Im new to this, but its a great site from where I see it.
    Shane