D'vorahDavida
Yetzirah

Can You Spell "Pedantic" ?
Mon Dec 01 2003

Having been recently corrected by some dear deardiary friends on some trifling spelling error, I have commandeered a one no less than our beloved and revered, Mr. Samuel Clemens to my defense. A personage of such literary gravitas as to summon a veritable black hole of testimony to support my assertion that the vagaries of English spelling are a burden almost to great to be born upon the backs of mere fallible humans.

And in my own defense I will add a personal observation, that some of the very BEST spellers write the very DULLEST stuff. It is as if the creative spark is doused with a deluge of cold water when its feet are too closely held to the fires of “proper spelling”. Concluding that some poor soul who does not spell a word exactly as the dictionary dictates is a fool, a dolt, and an uneducated bumbleton, is unfair in the extreme. As I have been wont to say myself in a journal written for my English class, “ It is no mark of great intelligence, in my mind, that one knows how to spell “pedantic”. It is more important to know what it MEANS.”
(The teacher heartily agreed)….

So without further ado, there follows a handful of quotes by our illustrious literary ancestor, the Mark Twain himself :

SPELLING
Why, there isn't a man who doesn't have to throw out about fifteen hundred words a day when he writes his letters because he can't spell them! It's like trying to do a St. Vitus dance with wooden legs.
- The Alphabet and Simplified Spelling speech, 12/9/1907

I have had an aversion to good spelling for sixty years and more, merely for the reason that when I was a boy there was not a thing I could do creditably except spell according to the book. It was a poor and mean distinction and I early learned to disenjoy it. I suppose that this is because the ability to spell correctly is a talent, not an acquirement. There is some dignity about an acquirement, because it is a product of your own labor. It is wages earned, whereas to be able to do a thing merely by the grace of God and not by your own effort transfers the distinction to our heavenly home--where possibly it is a matter of pride and satisfaction but it leaves you naked and bankrupt.
- Mark Twain's Autobiography

I never had any large respect for good spelling. That is my feeling yet. Before the spelling-book came with its arbitrary forms, men unconsciously revealed shades of their characters and also added enlightening shades of expression to what they wrote by their spelling, and so it is possible that the spelling-book has been a doubtful benevolence to us.
- Mark Twain's Autobiography

...simplified spelling is all right, but, like chastity, you can carry it too far.
- The Alphabet and Simplified Spelling speech, 12/9/1907

...ours is a mongrel language which started with a child's vocabulary of three hundred words, and now consists of two hundred and twenty-five thousand; the whole lot, with the exception of the original and legitimate three hundred, borrowed, stolen, smouched from every unwatched language under the sun, the spelling of each individual word of the lot locating the source of the theft and preserving the memory of the revered crime.
- Mark Twain's Autobiography


And here, I rest my case.

All further misspellings on my part, are to be considered “unconsciously revealed shades of my character, and enlightened shades of expression.” And there’s an end of it.

*The to instead of too, I maintain is an "enlightened shade of expression."
You are now free to move about the country.

I know a man who didn't get his Masters Degree because he took SO long to hand in his work that the powers that were told him to buzz off. He was a perfectionist and didn't want to hand in anything that might have an error in it. So he handed in nothing at all and got nothing at all for it. Again..... I rest my case..... :-) !!!!

(I LOVE you guys..... you know that......)


8 Comments
  • From:
    Jamisinc (Legacy)
    On:
    Mon Dec 01 2003
    Hear! Hear!
    Or should that be
    Here! Here!
    LOL
    I agree with you on the spelling. In fact my welcome page includes one of my favorite quotes. Andrew Jackson said, "It's a pretty stupid person that can only come up with one way to spell a word."
  • From:
    AeolianSolo (Legacy)
    On:
    Mon Dec 01 2003
    Chastised and forlorn, I am now reduced to snivelling; if you remove my talent to spell, all else I do will be drivelling.

    --Solo
  • From:
    RealmOfRachel (Legacy)
    On:
    Mon Dec 01 2003
    Bravo Yetzirah make a stand for the poor spellers, it's content that matters people should only quibble if the poor spelling gets in the way of meaning.

    Rach xxx
  • From:
    AQuietEvening (Legacy)
    On:
    Mon Dec 01 2003
    So you don't want to know that you wrote to instead of too in the first paragraph. LOL!!! Of course I am bummed to find out that my spelling ability is a gift, a mere talent. I thought it was my extreme intelligence. I thought it was something I mastered. So sad...

    ~QE
  • From:
    Pragmatist (Legacy)
    On:
    Mon Dec 01 2003
    Oh, that is absolutely a precious entry. And I absolutely adore Mark Twain!!!!

    Shalom
  • From:
    Sezrah (Legacy)
    On:
    Mon Dec 01 2003
    hehe, well said (and spelt)
  • From:
    Yarngirl (Legacy)
    On:
    Tue Dec 02 2003
    I feel SO much better now about the stuff I write. Thanks!

    Julie
  • From:
    Bookworm (Legacy)
    On:
    Tue Dec 02 2003
    I agree with you 100%. Great entry. I'd rather catch the shades of meaning and revelations about a person and enjoy what I'm reading, especially in this kind of forum, than be worried about how it's spelt. ;-)